Sign In to join the community | Help
Building Materials

Answered

Basement Wall Finishing which to use ? Owens Corning vs. R-13 with Blueboard & Tyvek

Hi,

I need some advice on finishing walls in the basement. I want to know quality & durability wise which one is better? Price of OWens corning is definitely very high.

1. Owens Corning walls with fiber glass insulation and fabric textured finish. This also has life time warranty.

2. Tyvek + R-13 fiberglass insulation and Blueboard

I am confused which one to choose in terms of quality & longevity. 

Any advice will be of great help.
Not what you were looking for ? Try posting a question
Posted 2014-06-01T14:34:32+0000  by Ashwinbijani Ashwinbijani
 
I've professionally finished basements using traditional construction materials and I've seen the Owens Corning product installed.  The biggest advantage to the Owens Corning product is speed of install and minimal mess.  Should the basement flood the product should dry with minimal damage and individual panels can be replaced should one be damaged.  As to the negatives:

  • At the time I was doing basements the Owens Corning product was double (or more) than what I would have charged for the same space.
  • Because it's essentially a "franchise" type business, quality of the install may vary.  I noticed a considerable difference in the quality of the trim work in the basements I was in.
  • A number of people have reported extremely high pressure sales tactics
  • There are very few choices as to finishes.  At least when I was involved the panels came in one color and to me looked kind of "commercial" (think office cubical).  There were about 3 choices in ceiling tile panels as well.  That may be an advantage to folks who aren't good at making design decisions.

Building Science Corporation has some excellent information on insulating and finishing a basement.  If you decide to use traditional materials I would strongly recommend reading through what they have to offer.

Best Answer

Posted 2014-06-02T03:49:48+0000  by Adam444
Adam,

Thanks so much for your reply. This is very helpful.

I agree on all on your points. They do have some variety in terms of wall finish now, 3 choices instead of 1.

I will look at building Science Corporation also. 

So quality wise still Owens Corning is the best in terms or water resistant, mold resistant, etc. Is this a correct statement?
Posted 2014-06-02T13:02:05+0000  by Ashwinbijani
Certainly drywall and water don't mix.  As I recall the Owens Corning product is relatively unaffected by water but the surface may show staining.  I can't comment on mold.

Any moisture issues must be addressed before finishing a basement.  If you have a sump pump, then a backup system is also a must.  For new construction, I would recommend waiting a year before finishing a basement.  That gives you can opportunity to experience all four seasons to see if there may be any problems with moisture.
Posted 2014-06-03T04:05:49+0000  by Adam444
Adam,

Thanks again for the advice. 

What do you suggest for addressing moisture issues? 

The house is 3 years old and there is no appearance of water in the basement but is very moist. Will surely use a backup system for sump pump. Any other pointers for installing bathrooms in the basement please share.

Thanks again.
Posted 2014-06-03T22:35:26+0000  by Ashwinbijani
 
Not what you were looking for ? Try posting a question

Topic
Categories+